Share Joy

Eat Pie

We're Remodeling!

We couldn’t be more excited for 2023! Our bakery is undergoing a remodel; we are expanding our kitchen production space so we can make more pies for you!
We hope to be complete by early spring/late winter.

Along with our remodel...

we are introducing the next chapter of the Colorado Cherry Company; Legacy Pie Co.
Same family, same pies, our new name highlights what’s important about our business — our legacy and of course, pies!
Read more herefrom the Denver Post.

Follow us on Instagram for updated hours as our construction remodel work comes to a close.
Feel free to call us at 3036356748 to learn more and see what we have left in stock. Stay tuned for our weekly online preorders coming soon!
Thanks everyone, we appreciate all your support!


We'd love to partner with you for catering & special orders!

Celebrate with pie

From weddings, birthdays, corporate gifts, or any celebration -- pie will bring smiles and is right for any occasion!

*Custom options available, delivery available*

Interested in working together? Shoot us an email or give us a call at the bakery for a consultation!

Let's Chat Pie

or give our bakery a call


Our Story

1929It all began at a small fruit stand outside of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. Great Grandma Katherine quickly builds a reputation for her pie and cider attracting visitors from all over the midwest. The pies are known for their flaky crust with homemade, honest ingredients.

Grandmother and Grandfather Lehnert, 1929
Colorado Cherry Co, 1950

1950sLehnerts bid farewell to the midwest and set up camp in Loveland, CO, where the region is known for their tart cherries. The Colorado Cherry Company is born and the family continues the tradition of pie and cherry cider.

2021Lehnert family opens shops by Estes Park, making the Cherry Co a go to stop for pie and cider on your way to Rocky Mountain National Park. 4th generation moves to Denver and opens on Tennyson St, March 2021 hoping to share all the goodness from Great Grandma’s recipes.

Roo and Elias Lehnert, 2021

We're always looking for awesome folks to join our pie family. Interested?

Send Us Your Resume